Manahawkin, NJ Pizza Delivery - Pietro's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria

Pietro's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria - Manahwkin, NJ

Order Online Call Us

Browse Our Favorites

Calamari Marinara

Order Now

Garlic Bread

Order Now

Chicken Parmigiana

Order Now

Lasagna

Order Now

Fettuccini Alfredo

Order Now

Linguini with Clam Sauce

Red or White

Linguini with Clam Sauce

Red or White

Order Now

Margherita

fresh mozzarella and basil

Margherita

fresh mozzarella and basil

Order Now

Caesar Salad

Order Now

Voted Best Italian Restaurant in Manahawkin, NJ

Experience a taste of la dolce vita at Pietro’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, voted Manahawkin’s BEST Italian food! We use Nonna’s recipes and the freshest ingredients to create authentic Italian dishes that will warm your heart and tantalize your taste buds. From mouthwatering pasta dishes to our prize-winning pizzas, our menu offers a slice of Italy for every craving. Come discover why Manahawkin locals love Pietro’s – it’s the taste of tradition served fresh!

Learn More About Us

What Our Customers Are Saying

Jay Maggio
07/27/2024

Pizza was good, but the only problem I had was with the gluten-free pie that I ordered. It wasn't baked on foil so it got cross-contaminated in the oven. Please be careful when making gluten-free dishes because when the food gets cross-contaminated people get sick

colleen panetta
07/24/2024

This is my favorite take-out around!!! So grateful for a delicious GLUTEN-FREE meal -- and even though they have lots of options for me -- I am addicted to their gluten-free stuffed shells. My non-gluten-free husband loves them as well!!!

Camille Dioguardi
07/04/2024

Not so sure about some of the reviews but I found the staff extremely courteous and attentive. Pizza was ready when they said and tasted just as I expected, great! We'll be back!

Colleen Panetta
06/24/2024

We ordered takeout -- as we often do. The BEST Gluten-Free stuffed shells EVER!!!!!!!!! Pietro's, please do not ever leave us!!!!!!!! You are our favorite date-night restaurant!!!

Bob Vogt
04/13/2024

The food and service have been great. Always a group of 6 or more. Food comes out hot and together. Quality is good. Portions are good.

Ike Jones
04/02/2024

I’m rating the pizza. Personally it’s my favorite pizza place. The Pizza is just the way I like it. Atmosphere is classic. Other things I’ve had have been very good as well. And it’s been around forever, check it out

robert keegan
01/05/2024

Never had a bad meal here, beat pizza around for sure. Cheese isn't greasy and its cooked perfect each time. The dinners are top notch as well!

Margaret Johnson
12/31/2023

I went there yesterday afternoon with my granddaughter. I had a issue with digest ingredients my roll on my meatballs sandwich I started coughing an feeling bad. Billy our waiter came over am asked if I would like a glass of water which helped me he bought me out another sandwich with the roll not toasted . kind considerate . food was awesome I can't tank Billy our servicer enough.

lance farina
12/23/2023

Been going there since ‘94. Hands down, best pizza in Stafford Township and all of LBI. Nick and his staff are the best and the pizza and food are delicious. Simply the best.

Alexis Morello
12/23/2023

First, I want to start off by saying these are the best meatballs I've ever had! Second, any party or event we have we always order trays of food from Pietros. Today, I had to pick up a few trays for xmas this year, and I had my toddler with me and my hands full. They had me pull my car up and loaded the food in for me. It's a simple yet really meaningful and helpful gesture. Service, food, and atmosphere are amazing, and I can't recommend Pietros enough!

Rolf Stutzer
11/13/2023

My wife is gluten sensitive so she ordered the gluten free stuffed shells with meat sauce. It's two days later and she is still talking about how good it was. I would recommend this place for everyone, great service, great food and a nice comfortable dining area. Just make sure you are ready to hear how good the food was for a few days.

Alex Kinon
10/12/2023

Nice local pizza place. Good food, generous portions, nice dining area, friendly staff, fair prices, and sometimes even live entertainment! Been going here since the early 80s. Great onions & anchovies pizza! A++

Larry Clay
10/03/2023

Pietro’s is my go-to pizzeria. The food is great, the prices are so much better than anything on the island, and the people are wonderful and professional. I usually don’t stay and eat, but occasionally I do, and they have a very nice restaurant - not just a pizza place with some seats. Can’t recommend them enough.

Eric 01
09/21/2023

I do not get to visit often but when I do, I am never disappointed. The portions are large and very reasonably priced. Excellent pizza and Chicken Parm is my favorite go to dinner item. Try this restaurant, you will definitely return.

Stephanie Frickenstein
08/22/2023

THIS PLACE WAS FANTASTIC! From the service to the food .. can’t go wrong!! I never find good Italian food in Jersey, but this place is heaven! Plus, the staff is super friendly I tried the pizza, which was also amazing! I will come back

KRISDAN Saillant
08/11/2023

My family and I have been going to Pietro's for years! We love it. Food is always delicious 😋🤤

Nilsa Montaner
07/24/2023

First time there but it definitely won't be our last. The service was great, prices were very reasonable and the food was amazing! The staff were super friendly.

Wayne and Kristen
07/02/2023

We used Pietros catering the last 2 weekends for parties and the food was great. Definitely our party go-to from now on. 👍👍

Rikki O'Hagan
06/25/2023

This place has one of the best slices in town. We love sitting down here. The service is good and the food comes out quickly. We only wish they would deliver, that's probably our only gripe.

Jim Nicolini
05/02/2023

As always food and service was excellent. Gnocchi, eggplant parm, chicken parm, and penne vodka was very good. Pizza is best in town hands down.

Fredric G Rubenstein
04/01/2023

The food at Pietro's is outstanding - as is the service. Family owned an operated, this is one of those hometown restaurants that blow the wannabe franchise places away.

Douglas M Schwartz
03/01/2023

The food was fantastic and the service was great!! Had the penne vodka and a cheese pizza absolutely delicious! Great atmosphere and the homemade orange cello is a must try.

Ron Trube
02/14/2023

Love this place! Great food and pizza, reasonable prices. Friendly atmosphere. Regular stop!

Joy Luedtke
02/13/2023

Quite simply put, THE BEST PIZZA in Ocean County. Best sauce ever. Worth the trip over from LBI. Wish they had a joint on The North End…

Mark Valeriani
01/22/2023

Pizza is pretty good when you get a pie - the slices are decent. I would stay away from the gluten free pie unfortunately it was very bad.

Robert Banul
01/19/2023

Pietro’s is by far the best pizza in Manahawkin. I have ordered pies on three separate occasions and have had perfectly cooked pies with the amount of toppings you would expect and taste was excellent.

Sukhwinder Singh
12/04/2022

If I could give this restaurant more ⭐️s I would, been coming here for over 10 years & Nick & his wife are the best. I grew up in Manahawkin & this was my go to place for some good pizza as a matter of fact I still come here. You guys are the best, I love this place.

Tarataffy
11/26/2022

Pizza was amazing. Veal parm sub was the best I have ever had. Excited to visit the in laws more to get to to to Pietro's again.

Deborah DeLuca
10/27/2022

This is the best pizza in the area originally I am from Brooklyn New York and this is equal or above what I've eaten there it is fabulous Services very good

Noel Heffernan
09/04/2022

One of the better Italian places around. Clean, good service and the food is very good. Worth the drive over the causeway from LBI. Better quality than any pizza places on the island. Nice people there and prices are fair.

Barbara Scaglione
08/02/2022

I had my sisters birthday celebration here and it was perfect from start to finish! Nick and his amazing team members are professional and friendly. The food is amazing and our server Taylor was great! Thank you for a great night!! Highly recommended you won't be disappointed!!!

Lori Purves
07/26/2022

Always have a consistent good meal. Nice waiters and waitresses. Pizza is delicious whatever kind you choose.

Lea Lenee'
07/19/2022

I've eaten here many times. The food is very good as is the service! No complaints! Will be returning!

Linda Richardson
06/29/2022

We are here on vacation and ordered in last night. We were extremely pleased with the meal and the delivery. We have a toddler with us and his pasta and meatball plate was great. Will definitely keep us in mind as a place to revisit

Amanda Ayala
06/27/2022

Took our grandmother here while visiting and everything was amazing. The fried calamari, the pizza, the shrimp scampi all delicious. The service was also top notch and I would recommend to anyone that is in the area.

Justin has Case
05/30/2022

Good NY style pizza. Everyone was friendly from the person on the phone, to the register, to the person cooking the pizza. Good prices. Watch the 3% credit card fee. Garlic knots not great. But if you’re in the mood for good pizza this is the place!

Julia Kreger
04/13/2022

Excellent pizza! The cheese they use is amazing and it just makes the tase perfect!

Alex Kinon
03/19/2022

Nice local pizza place. Good food, generous portions, nice dining area, friendly staff, fair prices, and sometimes even live entertainment! Great onions & anchovies pizza! A+

Tom
02/21/2022

I heard about the pizza and tried it. Perfect NY city style crunch on the crust. I haven't had anything else yet...

Jovan Mena
02/14/2022

Pietro's Italian Restaurant & Pizza not only has the best pizza in town but serves as a pillar of the community. They donate to our local Pinelands High School Wrestling team's concession stand during matches. I highly recommend taking your family and friends for an authentic Italian dinner. Rest assured that your money is well spent and circulates back to the community.

Brian Reiner
01/17/2022

Hidden Gem pizza place in Manahawkin. So one day we order the Buffalo wings and wow how amazing it was. The Buffalo seasonings is fried in the crisp so don't worry about messy hands and the hotness is mild. If I had to compare to Chegg or Cluck N Crab and if you like crispy wings this would be the go to place. If you don't believe me try it yourself and tell me I am wrong lol

Gale Serafin
01/16/2022

Best food ever. Pizza was the best so far in Manahawkin. We had Pizza this time. 😋

Gale Rankowski
01/16/2022

Best food ever. Pizza was the best so far in Manahawkin. We had Pizza this time. 😋

Joe Connolly
01/03/2022

Great Ceasar salad & absolutely awesome pizza. Staff is very friendly and helpful. Favorite Pizza place in the area for sure 👍

Larraine Kenney
01/01/2022

We have ordered several times and it is always great. The owners, staff and food is wonderful. Thank you

Deanna Tropeano
12/12/2021

Pizza is always delicious. Food is seasoned perfectly. Never had a bad meal dining in or take-out.

Jakki Gioia
12/11/2021

Always love Pietros. I had the fried Calamari as a dinner, which they don't list on the menu but they suggested it when I asked for both the appetizer and salad. There are always creative specials and they're the only place that serves angel hair. Love the chicken parm, meatballs, soup, pasta dishes, chicken...and it's a family run business with heart!

Susan King
12/06/2021

Servers are efficient and friendly. A weekly stop for us! Love the mussels marinara but everything is wonderful!

Jessi D
11/19/2021

Food is amazing but their chicken noodles soup is no joke the best around. Plus, you'll get the best service. Everyone is so kind

-Light -
10/25/2021

this is the most magnificent pizza I have ever had, the cheese was great and unlike other pizza places the cheese actually stretched I think this pizza place is better then domino's and the water was amazing it was nice and cold unlike some pizza place's with their worn water.

thisisseriously myemail
10/14/2021

I used to stop here all the time when I was bouncing on/off LBI regularly. Their pizza was always solid, delicious, crispy thin crust and they made great sandwiches, too (subs, where I'm from...). Although it was quite a while since I've been here last, I was happy to find it still just as consistent and enjoyable. I'm usually dropping in for take out- a quick slice, a cheesesteak or a hot sub - but this time we dined in and although it was a busy weekend night and service to be expected was challenged (possibly short handed as are all of the area restaurants at this time) - our food was still perfect and everyone enjoyed it. Looking fwd to going back soon!

Tim McCulla
10/12/2021

Nick and staff are always on their best. We visited on a busy Saturday night and everything was perfect. They perform well under pressure and still know how to have great customer service. Thanks Pietro's!

Diane Sindle
09/23/2021

Been dining there for 12 yrs.Food is always Soo Good.Love the family like atmosphere.Not an easy job having a Rest these days so I want to say Thank you for coming back.Appreciated

Pat Swick
09/12/2021

Pizza was excellent. Just the way I like it. Thin crust and lots of cheese. My friend had mussels marinara and gave it thumbs up. She scooped up all the remaining tasty sauce with crusty bread.

Damian B
09/01/2021

Stop in for a few slices of plain pizza. They were Hot, Nice Crunch, Good amount of cheese. The pizza sauce is absolutely fantastic, full of flavor. Should be a 4.8 Best Pizza in Manahawkin, 💥💥💥💥💥

Maureen Raso
07/31/2021

Best Philly cheese steak around. Wonderful service. I'll be back😁

Toni Ciarlariello
07/18/2021

We ordered 2 pizzas, veal marsala and garlic bread from Pietro's via their online system. It was easy and allowed us to put special requests in for each item. A staff member called just to clarify and make sure they understood our requirements. We were extremely happy with everything we ordered. The individual who requested veal marsala said it was the best veal she had ever eaten and the pizza's were perfectly cooked and very tasty too. Kudos to Pietros for consistently delivering delicious food!!

Margaret Johnson
06/27/2021

I had a meatball parrm an fries it was delicious. Our little waitress I forgot her name was the best an so friendly. Best pizza around

Theresa Josa
06/16/2021

AMAZING! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Best pizza & food in the area!

Alison Hill
06/11/2021

Pietro's has THE BEST Sicilian Pizza.... and I generally don't even like Sicilian Pizza! Their dinners are also quite good if you're looking for casual Italian food. I'm looking forward to dining in now that the Covid restrictions have been lifted.

jrz08510
06/10/2021

Best calzone that I have had one a very long time, made the way it is supposed to be made! Amazing cheese pie as well. My new go-to when I'm on LBI!!

Thomas Ziomek
04/19/2021

I tried Pitro’s and liked everything I had

Franches Frotto
03/12/2021

I got the Broccoli pizza and it was so good! Everyone else who had it with me loved it as well:) Very much would recommend ordering it👍

Ken Rea
11/28/2020

Been in town forever, always a friendly family working. Pizza is delicious and has a bit more of a sweeter tomato sauce which slaps.

Donna Harrington
10/30/2020

Best Italian food around! Food is always GREAT ! The people are always nice & service is always amazing! They have slacked in nothing during this Pandemic ! 👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍

Andrew Polidura
10/05/2020

Great pizza,my parents knew Nick personaly and my little league baseball team was sponcered by them you can see me on their wall

Al
07/30/2020

Every time I order its before the delivery date and hot out of the oven. It is the best quality food around town. I live more than 20 minutes away and my food is fresh every time. Best place to order through Gruhub. Professional on every level.

Our Favorite: Margherita Pizza

Manahawkin locals know, there’s only one place for the perfect Margherita pizza: Pietro’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria! Our award-winning Margherita is a symphony of simplicity – fresh mozzarella cheese, sun-ripened tomatoes, and fragrant basil on our signature crust, baked to a golden perfection. Every bite bursts with the taste of Italy. Looking for a classic done right? Look no further than Pietro’s. Experience Manahawkin’s favorite Margherita – come taste the difference!

Order Now

Locally Owned and Operated

About Us

712 E Bay Ave
Manahawkin, NJ 08050

Order Now

Store Hours

Monday
- 11:00 AM - 08:30 PM
Tuesday
- 11:00 AM - 08:30 PM
Wednesday
- 11:00 AM - 08:30 PM
Thursday
- 11:00 AM - 08:30 PM
Friday
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Saturday
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday
- 11:00 AM - 08:30 PM

Pizza in Manahawkin, NJ

08050 08092

Pietro's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria - Manahwkin, NJ

Browse Our Favorites

Calamari Marinara

Calamari Marinara

Garlic Bread

Garlic Bread

Chicken Parmigiana

Chicken Parmigiana

Lasagna

Lasagna

Fettuccini Alfredo

Fettuccini Alfredo

Linguini with Clam Sauce

Linguini with Clam Sauce

Margherita

Margherita

Caesar Salad

Caesar Salad

Voted Best Italian Restaurant in Manahawkin, NJ

What Our Customers Are Saying

Our Favorite: Margherita Pizza

Locally Owned and Operated

About Us

Pizza in Manahawkin, NJ

Come Visit Us